Ethics and Live Tissue Training - 1679 Words

The Ethical Dilemma of Live Tissue Training in the Military Environment By Aaron Smith 22 September 2012 Thesis: Over the past 11 years to date, the United States has endured almost 8000 casualties from two major conflicts (iCasualties.org, 2012). Although this number is staggering, we have also seen soldiers surviving injuries that were previously fatal (Philpott, 2005). This increase in survivability is largely due to the advancements in medical research and applied training. When it comes to military trauma, our warrior medics should be equipped with the most realistic training attainable. Although several simulation aids are used to provide this training, other methods such as live tissue training are still employed. In†¦show more content†¦In a recent media source, PETA defended their stance, stating, â€Å"they can drug an animal up, but they are sentient creatures that still feel pain and fear by being treated as a disposable commodity† (Gordon, 2009). The Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine (PCRM) agrees with PETA stating, â€Å"Because widely va lidated and accepted non-animal alternatives for chemical casualty management and combat trauma training courses exist, there is no justification for the use of live animals for these training purposes† (PCRM). Stakeholder Analysis: There are several individuals and organizations affected by this ethical dilemma. First and foremost are the casualties down range. Having highly trained personnel ready to treat and manage wounds on the battlefield is paramount in the survivability of these injured soldiers. Is the potential increase in fatalities on the battlefield justified by the elimination of live tissue training for warrior medics? When it comes to this life-versus-life assessment, which way is the â€Å"most ethical† choice? Secondly, the medically trained personnel must be taken into consideration. Without the most realistic training available, combat medics will not be as prepared to properly assess and treat casualties. A Marine Corps Staff Sergeant is quoted in saying, â€Å"I can honestly say that the military training that I received did not prepare me nearly as well as the live tissue training. I had toShow MoreRelatedEthics Is Defined As â€Å"The Branch Of Philosophy That Seeks1630 Words   |  7 PagesEthics is defined as â€Å"the branch of philosophy that seeks to understand the nature, justification, purposes, and founding principles of moral rules and the systems they compromise† (Pozgar, 2016, p. 3). Ethics deals with the â€Å"values relating to human contact specifically focusing on the rightness and wrongness of an action, along with the goodness and badness of motives and its ends† (Pozgar, 2016, p. 3). Ethics is studied to help us make sound judgments, right choices , and good decisions. It isRead MoreMedical Field That Deals With The Medical Care Of Babies, Children, Adolescents, And Young Adults821 Words   |  4 Pagesintended that this field would specialize in physiology, mental, emotional, and social structure of a child. In 1948 Dr. John Enders, Drs. Thomas H. Weller, and Dr. Frederick C. Robbin studied and tested the poliovirus on tissue. They soon successfully grew poliovirus in tissue culture. In 1952 Dr. Roland Scott was the very first African American Pediatrician was elected to the APS. Dr. Roland Scott was the professor of pediatrics at Howard University. In 1952 James Watson and Francis Crick discoveredRead MoreThe Debate Over Stem Cells And Cloning1398 Words   |  6 Pagesprevent diseases like heart disease. Scientists use cell cloning to make duplicates of biological material. https://stemcells.nih.gov/ says â€Å"Stem cells are unspecialized. One of the fundamental properties of a stem cell is that it does not have any tis sue-specific structures that allow it to perform specialized functions. For example, a stem cell cannot work with its neighbors to pump blood through the body (like a heart muscle cell), and it cannot carry oxygen molecules through the bloodstream (likeRead MorePrevention of a Surgical Site Infection1563 Words   |  6 Pagesnecessary to present well-documented presentation. This presentation would entail dangers relative to the surgical site infection and the need to eliminate or minimize the menace from the society. The process would involve presentation of data of lives lost because of surgical site infection, probable ways of minimizing the problem and number of cases the event affects or occurs within the existence of human beings. This presentation would occur under well-organized meeting by the organization. DuringRead MoreThe History and Career Outlooks of Geriatric Nursing Essay1138 Words   |  5 Pagesolder adult population about ways to decrease the risk of certain dis orders. Geriatric nursing act as managers during their everyday practice. Engage in counseling, communication, collaboration and teaching in a manner and reflects caring, advocacy, ethics, and professional standards. The nurses balance out their concerns with the patient, family, nursing and the rest of the team of nurses. Nurses have to be skilled in leadership, time management, building relationship, communication, and managing changeRead MoreThe Ethics Of The Animal Welfare Movement Essay1727 Words   |  7 Pagesanimals is still illegal in eighty percent of the world. Artificial tissue that is grown in a laboratory has proved to provide better results on how likely a contact dermatitis on a person will happen compared to animal testing (Cole, 2015). Human tissue can be donated or used after a person death, with the tissue that is donated they use it to make skin and eye models that are made from reconstituted human skin and other tissue. This development has replaced the cruel rabbit irritation test (AlternativesRead MoreOrgan Donation1787 Words   |  8 PagesOrgan Donation Tanecia Carter HCA 322 Health Care Ethics Medical Law Instructor: Instructor: Susan Vellek August 5, 2013 Organ Donation The process of taking functional organs and tissues from one person for transplantation into another individual is called organ donation. Whereas, any part of the body that performs a different and special function is referred to as an organ. Transplantation takes places quiteRead More Career in Dentistry Essay1728 Words   |  7 Pagesmany tasks and a strict code of ethics that dentists must master. What do dentists do? The best definition of dentists’ duties, according to Hopke, an American writer who wrote an educational book about various careers is, â€Å"Dentists attempt to maintain their clients’ teeth through such preventive and reparative practices as extracting, filling, cleaning, or replacing teeth.† Dentists perform corrective work such as straightening teeth and treating diseased tissue of the gums. These tasks are sometimesRead MoreAyten Pamuk. K. Goldsmith. Exhibition. 28 February 2017.1124 Words   |  5 Pagesanimals are treated’’ (â€Å"Mahatma Gandhi Quotes†). Right now, thousands of mice, rats, rabbits, primates, cats, dogs, and many other animals are living in barren cages in laboratories across the country. They scream in pain, suffer from frustration , live in loneliness, and want to be free. They can feel pain and suffer unlike what some people think (â€Å"Animals Used in Education†). They are not giving their consent or any other form of approval for the experiments to be done on them. Ä °f we want to beRead MoreRobotic Surgery1375 Words   |  6 PagesRobotic Surgery The ethics of robotic surgery is a multi-faceted topic of debate with many different viewpoints all worthy of deeper exploration and consideration. Medicine is ever-changing due to major technological innovations and government regulations. With all these changing factors in medicine, the focus should always be to provide the best possible care for the end user, or the patients. Is robotic surgery the best way to provide for the end user? There are many concerns and questions